EPISODE 53
When You Finally See Progress and Then It Disappears: Why Progress Isn't a Straight Line
Things had been good. Genuinely good. And then, out of nowhere, a setback, like none of the progress had ever happened. If you're in that exact moment right now, wondering whether you imagined the improvement entirely, I want you to know upfront: the progress was real. It didn't disappear.
Your dog suddenly going backwards after doing so well doesn't mean the work wasn't working.
Progress with a nervous system — yours or your dog's — is never a straight line. It's closer to a wave. Up, down, up again, down a little less far. Over time the overall trend moves in the right direction. But week to week, it doesn't look like steady improvement. It looks inconsistent, because that's actually how nervous systems re-pattern long-practised responses.
So when your dog has been doing really well and then suddenly falls apart, that's not evidence the progress wasn't real. It's what real progress looks like from the inside.
In this episode I explain why this particular kind of setback feels so much more confusing and worrying than an ordinary hard day, why your brain weighs the bad moment more heavily than weeks of good ones, and what to actually do when it happens — without spiralling into questioning everything you've worked for.
"This is a dip... The good weeks were real, and today was hard, you don't have to choose between those two things or let one cancel out the other."
Sian Lawley-Rudd - The Mindful Dog Parent, episode 53
Four Steps for Getting Your Footing Back
Name it as a wave, not a wall When a setback happens, try saying to yourself: "this is a dip, not a wall." A wall would mean the path is blocked and progress has stopped. A dip means the path is still there, just uneven today. This places the moment accurately within the bigger picture rather than treating it as the whole picture.
Resist the urge to re-evaluate everything After a setback, there's often an urge to question every decision you've made, was the approach wrong all along, should you have done something differently from the start. Try to resist making big judgments from inside a hard moment. Give it a few days. One hard day is not enough information to overhaul anything.
Look for what was different today Rather than asking "why is all the progress gone," ask "what was different about today specifically." Was the stress bucket fuller than usual? Was there a trigger that hadn't shown up in a while? Was your own nervous system more activated than usual? This question is more accurate and far less frightening than the global question.
Let the good weeks count, even now Actively remind yourself of the good stretch, specifically. Not vaguely, specifically. Name a few of the good moments - they happened, they were real. They're still real today, even alongside today's hard moment.
Share this episode with a fellow dog parent who needs it
Key Takeaways
• Progress with a nervous system is never a straight line, it's a wave, with the overall trend moving in the right direction even when any single point dips
• Your dog suddenly going backwards after doing well doesn't mean the progress wasn't real, it's what real, non-linear progress looks like from the inside
• Negative or threatening moments get weighted more heavily by the brain than calm, unremarkable ones, so one hard day can feel like it outweighs a month of good days, even though it doesn't
• A setback is a dip - the path is still there, just uneven today
• Resist the urge to re-evaluate everything after one hard day; give it time before making any big judgments
• The good weeks and today's hard moment can both be true at once, without contradiction
Explore all the episodes here:
Ready to Go Deeper?
If this episode resonated, my brand new business The Dog Parent Path™ was built for exactly this.
It’s nervous-system aware support for overwhelmed dog parents all over the world who are doing everything they can and still finding it hard.
Start your journey on the Dog Parent Path with my free One Minute Reset tool - step by step, 60 seconds to reset yourself and your dog. Use the interactive or audio version.
Use it to calm the dread before walking your dog, after a reactive episode, at the end of a difficult walk to stop the rumination, or at any time your mind and body needs a reset. Download it here:
